May 17, 2021

May 17, 2021

Your Source for Free Speech,
Talk Radio, Podcasts, and News.

The Nuclear Fusion Delusion (Part One)

by | May 14, 2019 |

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

It seems like only yesterday that the senior author of this article (Dr. Lehr) was walking past Albert Einstein on the streets of Princeton, New Jersey, nodding to the great man and receiving a nod in return. It was not exactly yesterday, of course, but a frequent occurrence from 1953 to 1955 when I (Dr. Lehr) was a student at the university there.

In those days, Dr. Einstein spoke frequently about the forthcoming wonders of nuclear fusion energy. He predicted that its grand benefits would arrive about 50 years hence. Unfortunately, 50 years later, long after Dr. Einstein’s passing, most physicists still predicted that we would have to wait yet another 50 years before the generation of electricity through controlled nuclear fusion may be possible. That prediction has not changed much in the past decade.

We think it is time to back off on the highly costly research currently being conducted on fusion. In deference to Einstein, in the mid-1950s, we had yet to learn through experimentation about the huge obstacles that we now recognize. While 100s of billions of dollars have now been spent in the effort to prove Einstein correct, success is now unlikely.

While in all current nuclear reactors, which have operated since the 1950s, atoms are split to produce energy, nuclear fusion normally requires two hydrogen nuclei to fuse together leaving excess energy behind to harness. Our Sun is a massive nuclear fusion reactor. It works because it offers a tremendous gravitational force to apply pressure to the nuclei within, while they bombard each other in attempts to overcome the huge electrostatic repulsion resulting from their identical positive charges. Only when they do overcome this repulsion does the fusion occur that gives off excess energy.

On Earth, we are unable to replicate the pressure at the core of the Sun where fusion occurs, and so we must create temperatures of at least 100 million degrees Celsius, far hotter than in the Sun, to encourage fusion to occur. But the required confinement of the fusion has not been created economically. And, thus far, while a tiny amount of energy has been produced in a donut-shaped magnetic fusion container, called a tokamak, in CERN, Switzerland, years ago, the energy required to produce this energy has been vastly greater.

More than a dozen experiments are going on around the world. The largest tokamak in the world is in Oxfordshire, UK but the best funded has been ongoing for many years at the International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER) at Saint Paul-lez-Durance, France funded by the US, Russia, China, Japan, the European Union, South Korea, and India.

Dr. Daniel Jassby, writing in The Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists on April 19, 2017 said that, after 25 years working on nuclear fusion experiments at the Princeton Plasma Physics Lab, “I began to look at the fusion enterprise more dispassionately in my retirement, concluding that a fusion reactor would be far from perfect, and in some ways close to the opposite.”

The real problem is attempting to scale down the reactions in the Sun which burns hydrogen at enormous temperature and density, sustained with unlimited time, creating benign reaction products, primarily helium. On Earth we have none of these conditions so, besides having to generate temperatures even hotter than the Sun, we must use heavier neutron-rich isotopes of hydrogen which are deuterium and tritium. While the former is readily available in sea water, the latter is only found in minute quantities in nature and so must be manufactured in a nuclear reactor.

The proponents of fusion reactors believe that their byproducts are totally harmless. However, fusion reactors that must burn neutron-rich isotopes have byproducts that, in Jassby’s words, are “anything but harmless.” The neutron stream generated in a fusion reactor leads to four problems including:

  • radioactive waste,
  • radiation damage to structures,
  • the need for biological shielding,
  • the potential for creating weapons grader plutonium.

Jassby says that the latter problem adds to “the threat of nuclear weapons proliferation, not lessening it, as fusion proponents would have it.”

But these reactors, if ever brought on line, would also have many of the problems that have beset fission reactors, which include high coolant demands, large operating costs, and on-site power demands that would lessen the output of power made for sale.

In magnetic confinement fusion, the only practical solution available so far, electrical and magnetic fields are used to control the high temperature fusion fuel known as “plasma,” a difficult-to-control material consisting of free nuclei and electrons. Inertial confinement in a circular tunnel is required with laser beams used to squeeze and heat the plasma to the extreme temperatures mentioned earlier.

If we have your attention now, wait, there is more, much more that we will deal with on America Out Loud next week. The thought that fusion reactors will become an economical power source any time in the foreseeable future is a pipe dream.

NOTE: Technological advances may someday make the generation of electricity through controlled nuclear fusion possible. Through the use of high-speed computer technology, we are better able to control the magnetic field to hold the plasma for longer time frames, for example. Nevertheless, there are a myriad list of problems that make it improbable that fusion will ever be economic. We discuss these problems in part 2 of this article. 


Dr. Jay Lehr is a Senior Policy Analyst with the International Climate Science Coalition and former Science Director of The Heartland Institute. He is an internationally renowned scientist, author, and speaker who has testified before Congress on dozens of occasions on environmental issues and consulted with nearly every agency of the national government and many foreign countries. After graduating from Princeton University at the age of 20 with a degree in Geological Engineering, he received the nation’s first Ph.D. in Groundwater Hydrology from the University of Arizona. He later became executive director of the National Association of Groundwater Scientists and Engineers.

Tom Harris is Executive Director of the Ottawa, Canada-based International Climate Science Coalition, and a policy advisor to The Heartland Institute. He has 40 years experience as a mechanical engineer/project manager, science and technology communications professional, technical trainer, and S&T advisor to a former Opposition Senior Environment Critic in Canada’s Parliament.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Use the code ‘OUTLOUD’ and receive your 20% discount on your first order.

America’s Marxist Termite Infestation

America’s Marxist Termite Infestation

The American body politic has drifted far afield from the Madisonian constitutional moorings of check and balance controls by three separate co-equal branches to an imperial executive that rules through edicts, guidance directives, and appointed publicly unaccountable agency bureaucrats — such as the EPA, FBI/DOJ and Department of Education.

How to Defund Unconstitutional Government Programs

How to Defund Unconstitutional Government Programs

Here are a few examples of how Constitutional Conservatives can use the “defund” movement to move the country back in the direction of constitutionally limited government. There is nothing in the Constitution about government-funded elementary schools, government-funded universities, and government-funded free food. Defund all government agencies not enumerated in the Constitution…

Israel Smashes Hamas’ Terror Tunnels

Israel Smashes Hamas’ Terror Tunnels

Israel secured an undeniable victory in Gaza this week. By eliminating the terrorist fighters in the tunnels, Israel may have saved hundreds of Palestinian lives, lives that otherwise might have been lost, because they were forced to be human shields for the Hamas officers and fighters who were hiding among them. By driving the terrorists into the tunnels, these lives were spared…

Biden, Kerry and the Moderate Iranian Fantasy

Biden, Kerry and the Moderate Iranian Fantasy

The most important revelations pertaining to the mindset of the Ayatollahs’ leadership, its priorities, and internal conflicts came from the leaked recording. These details prove that the terrorist regime is hell-bent on military domination of the Middle East by every means possible, especially by proxy terrorist entities, such as Hamas in Gaza, Hezbollah in Lebanon, Kataaib in Iraq, and Houthis in Yemen, to name a few…

The Science of Pseudoscience for Sinister Gain

The Science of Pseudoscience for Sinister Gain

Real science no longer plays a role in establishing pandemic policies; it is the enemy of the rogue state. These are cases of good science leading to evil outcomes, however, you wish to analyze them. What is most concerning is that the Wuhan viral manipulation actors include the brainchildren of eugenics advocates, such as the Bill Gates and the Rockefeller foundations. Did they not fund this research?

Biden is on Losing Side of All Key Voting Issues

Biden is on Losing Side of All Key Voting Issues

The Democrat Left’s influential alignment with radical neo-Marxist “woke” ideologies and agendas are bound to be prominently featured by Republicans in the 2022 midterms. Amid rising violent disorder, Left-aligned defund the police, and Second Amendment assaults are even opposed by many properly worried traditional Democrat voters, including most…

Hamas ‘Rain’ of Terror:  Israel Fights Back

Hamas ‘Rain’ of Terror: Israel Fights Back

Today, as the Israeli-Arab violence continues to spiral out of control, Israel is fighting a two-front (and maybe even a three-front) war, and the terrorists show no sign of giving in or giving up. Every war that Israel has been forced to engage in is a fight for survival. Hamas’ mission is clear. Hezbollah has the same mission. As does the Palestinian Authority. The destruction of the Jewish state and the creation of a…

GOP Bill Calls for CCP-Infiltrated Colleges to Fess Up

GOP Bill Calls for CCP-Infiltrated Colleges to Fess Up

In his remarks, Sen. Chuck Grassley said: “One member of the communist regime said: ‘The Confucius Institute is an appealing brand for expanding our culture abroad. It has made an important contribution toward improving our soft power. The ‘Confucius’ brand has a natural attractiveness. Using the excuse of teaching Chinese language, everything looks reasonable and logical.’”

Is The CDC Trustworthy Anymore? 

Is The CDC Trustworthy Anymore? 

Tucker Carlson wonders why Dr. Fauci hasn’t been indicted yet. He’s the guy in charge of America’s response to the Covid infestation, isn’t he; and it appears he’s the guy who funded the NIAID’s Wuhan research lab that he denies. Could Dr. Fauci be charged one may ask? Well, he did approve the Federal NIAID Grant to the Wuhan Labs, in explicit contravention of Federal Law banning US funding of “Gain of Function” experiments…

Your Source for Free Speech, Talk Radio, Podcasts, and News


Here we take on the challenges of our generation so that we can preserve future generations.

LISTEN on the iHeart Radio Network


Get the Free APP to listen to great talk radio and podcast:

Free APP

Subscribe and Listen on Your Favorite APP

Apple Podcasts
Google Podcasts

If you love to listen, you'll love America Out Loud Podcasts!

Our Columnists and Show Hosts

Apple Podcasts

Support wounded and fallen police officers. We need your help.

Apple Podcasts
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap